Newcastle’s improving defence offers a stronger platform after injury-hit start
- Mark Jensen
- 508 views
Newcastle conceded 13 goals in their first six league matches and three in their next four. A steadier back line could help the team take control.

Newcastle United’s defensive numbers have changed sharply over the opening 10 Premier League matches. They conceded 13 goals in the first six, then three in the next four. That improvement is meaningful, even if it hasn’t yet been matched by a consistent run of results or a settled back four.
Injuries have kept the back line in flux
Newcastle have used three different defensive combinations in those 10 league matches. Amar Dedić, Malick Thiaw, Sven Botman and Lewis Hall started together in the first four: the 2-2 draw with Liverpool, the 2-0 win at Spurs, the 2-2 draw with Bournemouth and the 4-1 defeat at Leeds. That stretch shows both the promise and the vulnerability of the unit, with two goals conceded in each of the first three games before the heavy loss at Leeds.
Lewis Miley then filled in at right-back for the next three matches, alongside Thiaw, Botman and Hall. Newcastle beat Hull 2-1, lost 4-1 at Coventry and fell 1-0 to Aston Villa. Miley is a midfielder by trade, and the Villa goal came after a cross from the right got past him. That moment needs to be read in the context of an injury-hit defence, rather than treated as a simple measure of his ability.
The next change brought Dedić back at right-back, with Fabian Schär and Dan Burn in central defence and Hall on the left. Newcastle won 2-0 at Crystal Palace, then lost 1-0 to Everton. Thiaw returned for Burn’s side in the 1-1 draw at Fulham. The repeated changes make it harder for the goalkeeper and defenders to build the timing and trust that come with playing together regularly.
The recent goals conceded tell a more complicated story
Newcastle’s three goals against in their last four league matches came in different circumstances. Villa scored after the cross that eluded Miley. Everton’s goal followed a low cross that Lukas Hornicek allowed to slip beneath him, a clear error from the goalkeeper. Fulham’s equaliser came after deflections involving Thiaw in the build-up and Burn at the finish.
Those moments don’t make the defence faultless. Opponents had other opportunities in those matches, and individual mistakes still cost Newcastle. But the sequence offers a fairer picture than simply counting goals: one came during a makeshift right-back’s adjustment to the role, one from a goalkeeper error, and one took two deflections to beat Hornicek.
Since the defeat at Coventry, Newcastle have conceded just three times across the next six and a half hours of Premier League football, including added time. That works out at roughly one goal every 130 minutes. The sample is still small, but it points to a side defending with greater resilience.
There’s a clear difference between that run and the opening six matches. Newcastle scored six goals across their four games against Liverpool, Coventry, Leeds and Bournemouth, yet took only two points from a possible 12. Their earlier wins over Tottenham and Hull showed another side of the team: a single goal conceded across more than three hours of football against those two opponents.
Returning players could strengthen the partnership
Dan Burn’s return gives Newcastle a centre-back option who was missed during the first seven league matches. He has started three Premier League games since returning from a lengthy injury spell, with Newcastle conceding two goals in those appearances. His recent displays for England add to the sense that he can bring experience and solidity to the back line.
Thiaw, meanwhile, has shown his quality at Newcastle and started Germany’s last three matches under Jürgen Klopp, in which they conceded one goal. The Fulham match offered a glimpse of what Burn and Thiaw might provide together: a more settled central pairing, with the physical presence and defensive range to give the team a dependable base.
Hall has impressed for both Newcastle and England. At left-back, his quality gives the side a reliable outlet as well as defensive ability. Tino Livramento’s return to the Premier League matchday squad at Fulham is another positive, though his fitness has been a persistent concern. If he can build consistency, he offers a strong option at right-back. If injuries continue to limit him, Dedić has shown he can cover the position after arriving in the Premier League and stepping into a difficult team situation.
Hornicek has had an uneven start, with the Everton goal a costly lapse. He has also shown enough to suggest he can contribute, particularly if Newcastle can provide regular protection through a settled defence. The goalkeeper’s confidence and decision-making should benefit from familiarity with the players in front of him.
A firmer base could change Newcastle’s attacking rhythm
Newcastle’s recent defensive progress hasn’t yet brought a matching surge in points. In their last four league games, a couple more goals at the other end could have turned the run into 12 points from 12; instead, they took four. That gap makes the defensive improvement more important, not less. A team that gives away fewer clear openings has more room to manage matches and wait for its attackers to find their rhythm.
The personnel are there to build a capable back four, with Hall, Burn and Thiaw offering international experience and Livramento a further option if he can stay fit. Dedić’s cover matters, too, because injuries have already forced Newcastle to improvise. The next step is continuity: if the defence can keep its recent level while key players regain fitness, Newcastle will have a stronger platform to control games and make their attacking quality count.
