Skip to the stories
Transfers & Rumours

Celtic and Rangers Must Play Scottish Cup Home Ties Behind Closed Doors After Appeals

  • Alasdair Munn
  • 507 views

The clubs’ appeals removed a suspended penalty but left the empty-stadium order and £100,000 visitor payment intact.

Celtic and Rangers Must Play Scottish Cup Home Ties Behind Closed Doors After Appeals

The appeals changed one part of the punishment, but Celtic and Rangers will still have to stage their next Scottish Cup home ties without spectators. Each club must also pay its visitors £100,000 to cover lost ticket income. The ruling leaves the central sanctions in place while removing a further penalty that would have applied if trouble happened again.

That distinction explains why Celtic called its appeal partially upheld, even as it condemned the remaining punishment. Rangers had not commented when the decision became public. For both clubs, the immediate practical effect depends on the Scottish Cup draw: the order takes effect when either side next receives a home tie.

The appeal’s limited success

A Scottish FA appellate tribunal heard the cases on Monday. It upheld the closed-stadium requirement and the £100,000 payment, first set out when the original punishment was announced at the end of August. The tribunal did, however, set aside the suspended sanction that would have triggered another stadium closure if either club were involved in repeat trouble.

So the appeals narrowed the consequences without changing the punishment supporters are most likely to notice. The next affected home cup match will be played in an empty ground, and the visiting club will receive the specified payment. Removing the suspended penalty gives the clubs some relief over future consequences, but it does not restore access for home fans at that tie.

Celtic challenge the comparison

Celtic responded within minutes, saying it remained “extremely disappointed” by what it called an “excessive and disproportionate punishment”. The club objected to the tribunal’s treatment of the two groups of supporters, arguing that their actions were different and should not have been treated as equivalent.

The club said it had not defended supporters entering the pitch, while asking for the context of what it described as an emotional, celebratory moment to be considered. Its statement also argued that Celtic had no responsibility for the stadium safety arrangements on the day, and that this should have been taken into account when the sanctions were established.

That complaint goes to the heart of the appeal’s public significance. The order applies equally to the two clubs, but Celtic’s stated objection is that equal treatment does not reflect what it sees as different conduct and different responsibilities. The tribunal’s decision leaves that dispute unresolved in practical terms: both clubs face the same immediate match-day restrictions and payment.

The Ibrox quarter-final that led to the case

The disciplinary case followed the Scottish Cup quarter-final at Ibrox in March. Celtic advanced after a 4-2 win on penalties. Supporters from both ends entered the pitch after the match, and pyrotechnics and other objects were thrown. Police officers were among those hurt. By 25 August, 43 people had been arrested.

An independent review led by Mark Blackbourne, published in July, found failings at both clubs. It said the scenes “came within a very small margin of becoming a violent mass confrontation”. That assessment formed part of the context for the sanctions announced several weeks later, after which both clubs appealed.

The £100,000 is due within 30 days of the affected match being played. Its timing therefore follows the fixture itself: the payment is tied to the home cup tie, rather than being triggered simply by the appeal ruling. The precise date and visiting club will depend on the future draw.

What comes next for the clubs and fans

For supporters, the most direct consequence is clear: when Celtic or Rangers next host a Scottish Cup tie, their home crowd will be absent. The visitors will receive £100,000 in compensation for ticket income lost because of the closed-stadium order. The ruling offers no date yet, since neither club’s next home cup opponent is established here.

The decision also lands amid a separate restriction on derby crowds. In September, Celtic and Rangers agreed that visiting supporters would not attend their league derbies this season in SPFL competitions. That arrangement is distinct from the Scottish Cup sanctions, but it means away fans are already missing from Old Firm league fixtures this season.

Celtic’s attention also returns to the league, where the club sits four points clear after drawing 2-2 with Dundee United in midweek. That position gives the appeal ruling a wider season context: the cup tie is still to come, while league demands continue now. The tribunal has removed the extra suspended consequence, but the empty stands and visitor payment remain waiting for the draw to make them concrete.

Source: Alasdair Munn · thecelticstar.com

Neighbouring cells